Cottage rentals in Montauk

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Montauk

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

SUPERHOST

Cottage in Montauk

Sharkey Cottage

Sept & Oct are beautiful in Montauk! Lovely Sharkey waterfront, large 1BR cottage sits on a great lawn w/4 other cottages on Ft Pond Bay. Sharkey is steps away from our private beach w/ private beach path & benches, has indoor & outdoor showers & dining areas, wrap around patio, full kitchen, gas grill & is dog-friendly. A unique Montauk experience w/ quiet beach & the best sunsets in town! Walking distance to LIRR, Duryea's Lobster Deck & Market, Roberta's Pizza, Surf Lodge & The Montauket.

$468 per night

SUPERHOST

Cottage in Montauk

Laid-Back Surf Shack steps to beach & downtown!

Historic Montauk fisherman's cottage tastefully re-made into a stylish 2-bd beach getaway located within walking distance of the beach & downtown. Plywood accents, handmade furniture & eclectic finishes create a cool, laid-back vibe. Westward views across Fort Pond provide sunlight all day & beautiful sunsets. Fenced in yard with gas BBQ, table & string lights. Designed by Studio MTK, this is Montauk at its best! Find us on IG @studiomtk or @casabungo EH Rental Registry: 22-1360

$466 per night

Cottage in Montauk

Waterfront Cottage, Fort Pond MTK

Really unique cottage perched above Fort Pond with epic views and relaxed bohemian vibes. The cottage is private with a private deck on shared grounds with a fire pit, hammocks, paddle boards, kayak, and lake access. The grounds are expertly landscaped and take full advantage of fort pond views. We do live on the property full time and enjoy making our space a safe and clean environment.

$395 per night