Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Jay County

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Jay County

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Home in Hartford City
Rustic Lake house with HOT TUB and Pool Table
Come relax in our cozy 1978 Lake House! Conveniently located between Muncie and Hartford City, 16 min. from Taylor University, 24 min. from Ball State, and 10 seconds from the dock! Enjoy the outdoors-Take out the kayaks, go fishing, enjoy the lake, soak up the sights in the hot tub, and maybe end the night with a campfire! Staying in?-Shoot some pool on the 1800's pool table, pull out a board game with the family, or just relax in the four-season sunroom while watching the sunset. Come unwind!
$134 per night
Guesthouse in Albany
Rustic Converted Barn 1- Bedroom open floor plan
Enjoypeacefull country living with the whole family at this rustic converted barn with full modern conveninces. Enjoy your morning coffee taking in the view looking out over the stocked bass pond. Cool off in the afternoon with a swim in the pool or relax in front of the TV taking in your favorite netflix serries. This one bedroom open floor plan apartment has a full kitchen huge deck with a convient grill. Enjoy the evening sitting around the large firepit listening to the sounds of country
$123 per night
Private room in Upland
Cozy, private guest suite in Upland
This lovely, private suite is situated near the best of Upland: Taylor University (5 minute walk), Ivanhoe's (local legend), The Bridge (coffee shop), and Walnut Creek (grocery store). Whether you are visiting campus or not, this private suite offers guests a cozy place to rest and refresh. When you stay, we are only an quick ask away. You'll love the convenience, quiet and safe neighborhood, and top-notch hospitality ready and waiting for you.
$48 per night

Other great vacation rentals in Jay County

Cottage in Upland
Cottage on 2nd No Cleaning Fee Quiet Walk to Shops
$91 per night
Home in Fort Recovery
Remodeled 3 Bedroom house in town of Ft. Recovery
$108 per night
Home in Upland
Brick House Upland
$118 per night
Place to stay in Muncie
Carriage House Loft Apartment
$61 per night
Guesthouse in Muncie
Burlingwood Guest House
$33 per night
Home in Berne
The Franklin Green House in the heart of Berne, IN
$126 per night
Guest suite in Muncie
Guest Suite in Secluded Setting (NW Muncie)
$57 per night
Home in Muncie
Travelers Paradise
$110 per night
Guesthouse in Eaton
Cozy Pool House in the Country on 25 acres
$148 per night
Guest suite in Muncie
The Eagles Nest, two bedroom retreat.
$79 per night
Guest suite in Muncie
Cozy One bedroom duplex
$77 per night
Home in Celina
Bungalow by the Lake
$100 per night
  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Indiana
  4. Jay County