Skip to content

Luxury rentals in Paynes Bay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated luxury vacation rentals in Paynes Bay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

New Mansion
LUXE
Entire villa · 8 guests · 7 beds · 4.5 baths
New Mansion
Shutters Coral Cove
LUXE
Entire villa · 6 guests · 4 beds · 3 baths
Shutters Coral CoveCoral Cove 5 - Shutters
Sandy Cove 201
LUXE
Entire villa · 9 guests · 7 beds · 3 baths
Sandy Cove 201British charm meets Caribbean flair above the sea

Luxury rentals for every style

The right home for your next dream getaway

  • Featured Homes
  • Flexible bookings
  • Ready to book homes

Popular amenities for Paynes Bay luxury vacation rentals

  • Kitchen
  • Wifi
  • Pool
  • Free parking on premises
  • Air conditioning
  • Gated property

Other great luxury vacation rentals in Paynes Bay

LUXEEntire villaRating 5 out of 5; 7 reviews
Old Trees Firefly
$2,000 / night
LUXEEntire villaRating 5 out of 5; 6 reviews
High Breeze
$1,950 / night
LUXEEntire villaRating 4.86 out of 5; 7 reviews
Old Trees Casuarinas
$1,750 / night
LUXEEntire villaRating 4.75 out of 5; 8 reviews
Sunset 104 at Old Trees
$950 / night
LUXEEntire villaRating 5 out of 5; 5 reviews
Old Trees Penthouse #302
$4,000 / night
LUXEEntire villaRating 5 out of 5; 4 reviews
Coral Cove 6 - The Ivy
$525 / night
LUXEEntire villa
Casablanca
$3,000 / night
LUXEEntire villa
Coral Cove 8
$679 / night
LUXEEntire villaRating 4.67 out of 5; 3 reviews
Heronetta
$1,750 / night
LUXEEntire villaRating 4.4 out of 5; 5 reviews
Smugglers Cove - The Penthouse
$2,500 / night
LUXEEntire villa
Smugglers Cove 4
$995 / night
LUXEEntire condominium (condo)
The One at The St. James
$1,400 / night