Skip to content

Eagle Bay cabins

Book unique cabins, vacation rentals, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated cabins in Eagle Bay

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Cabin in Eagle Bay
Renovated Camp with Beach Rights down the Street!
Walk down the quiet street to enjoy our access to two private homeowners association beaches, only for neighborhood use! One beach overlooks the mountains, the other in a sheltered cove with a sandy swim area and picnic tables. Located less than 10 miles to Old Forge and 2 miles from Inlet. Dine together on the new pine screened porch, sit together by a fire, or relax in one of two living rooms. Our cabin is walking distance to ice cream, doughnuts, a bar, and more- just park the car and relax!
$200 per night
Cabin in Inlet
Cozy Adirondack Mountain Cabin - Sleeps 9!
Welcome to Camp Bentwood! Enjoy this four-season destination in the heart of the Adirondacks located just a few minutes from Inlet and 10 minutes from Old Forge. Enjoy the scenic fall foliage and winter snowmobiling, as we are located on a primary snowmobile trail. In the spring/summer enjoy the public boat launch on fourth Lake and Arrowhead Public Park in Inlet, plus nearby hiking and biking trails and horseback riding just down the road. Come experience all the Adirondacks has to offer!
$173 per night
Cabin in Eagle Bay
Beautiful 3 Bedroom Cabin w/ Private Beach Access.
Welcome to Camp ZZ. Just 2 miles from Inlet & 8 miles from Old Forge sitting lakeside off Rt28 w/ access to 2 private beaches. One is even dog friendly! Sleeps 10 comfortably w/ 3 bedrooms and 1 sleeping loft. The upstairs master offers a private screened-in porch w/ relaxing Adirondack Chairs. Hello, perfect 1st cup of coffee spot. You will find a great selection of lawn games & even a large screen/projector for family movie nights. We hope to host you and yours! (BYO sheets & towels)
$400 per night

Stay near Eagle Bay's top sights

Photo of The Donut Shop of Eagle Bay
The Donut Shop of Eagle Bay4 locals recommend
Photo of Big Moose Yamaha Inc
Big Moose Yamaha Inc3 locals recommend
Photo of Clark's Marina
Clark's Marina7 locals recommend

Eagle Bay vacation rentals

Cottage in Eagle Bay
Camp Orvis by West Pond
$219 per night
Cottage in Eagle Bay
Private Vacation Home on Big Moose Lake
$350 per night
Private room in Eagle Bay
Private Room with king bed on Big Moose Lake
$79 per night
Home in Eagle Bay
Big Moose Hideaway (With Heated Garage!)
$275 per night
Home in Inlet
Cozy Camp Mohegan on Uncas Rd
$195 per night
Private room in Eagle Bay
The Little Fox 2
$74 per night
Home in Old Forge
The Boathouse on Fourth Lake
$495 per night
Home in Old Forge
Camp Seneca in Hollywood Hills
$176 per night
Cottage in Old Forge
Birches at 4 Seasons Cottages 4th Lake, Old Forge
$171 per night
Guest suite in Eagle Bay
Gibbs Cottage- Big Moose
$205 per night
Home in Eagle Bay
West Bay Hideaway
$425 per night
Home in Eagle Bay
Moose Heaven at BIgMoose Lake
$325 per night
  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Herkimer County
  5. Eagle Bay