Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Cayuta Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cayuta Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Home in Alpine
The Glen Mary House-A Peaceful Country Home
This newly renovated home is a true gem if you’re looking to spend time in the country, but still be close to the attractions that set the Finger Lakes apart! Built in 1938, The Glen Mary House is the perfect retreat, being minutes from Watkins Glen, Ithaca, Elmira, Corning and Geneva. Whether you enjoy hiking, hunting, fishing, shopping, wine tasting, spending time on one of the Finger Lakes, or just want to stay in and relax, this home will accommodate your needs and offer a beautiful sunset!
$179 per night
Home in Odessa
Relax with the whole family at our modest 3 bedroom, one bath home which was recently updated with a new kitchen and bathroom. This lovely home is adjacent to one of regions finest creameries and dairy farm where one can purchase local cheese and dairy products. An easy drive to Watkins Glen (10 min), Ithaca (25 min), and Elmira (20 min) makes this the perfect home for Cornell, Ithaca, and Elmira graduations. Close to state parks, Watkins Glen NASCAR track, & the Finger Lakes Wine Trail.
$100 per night
Home in Burdett
1875 Renovated Schoolhouse in the Finger Lakes!
Relax and get cozy in this renovated schoolhouse built in 1875. Nestled atop a hill on 2.5 acres, with absolutely stunning views with surroundings that are peaceful and private. A perfect retreat for couples and friends, you're within minutes of the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, the famously gorgeous Watkins Glen State Park, and the renowned Watkins Glen International Racetrack. Want to simply relax and rejuvenate at the FLX Schoolhouse? It's the perfect retreat to do that too!
$216 per night

Other great vacation rentals in Cayuta Lake

Chalet in Ithaca
Naturalists' Retreat
$252 per night
Rental unit in Montour Falls
Second Floor in Wine Country - Next to a Waterfall
$164 per night
Cabin in Hector
Wine Trail Cabin with a view -cabin 2
$177 per night
Rental unit in Hector
Private Lakefront on Seneca Wine Trail
$160 per night
Tiny home in Watkins Glen
Boat House/Fish Room-Seneca Canal,Watkins Glen
$123 per night
Cottage in Ithaca
The Timber Garden Cottage
$154 per night
Cabin in Burdett
Boujee Bungalow: Finger Lakes Wine Country
$349 per night
Home in Alpine
Beautiful Lakefront Property
$539 per night
Cabin in Newfield
CreekWalk Cabin
$174 per night
Home in Alpine
Perfectly situated four bedroom Finger Lakes house
$497 per night
Rental unit in Odessa
Seneca Lake Country House with pond
$61 per night
Tiny home in Burdett
Micro-Cabin Stay in the Finger Lakes! (History)
$227 per night

Other types of stays on Airbnb

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Schuyler County
  5. Catharine
  6. Cayuta Lake