Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Cayuga Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cayuga Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Chalet in Ithaca
Naturalists' Retreat
Retreat to paradise at this cozy cottage in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Charming custom woodwork offers a unique, rustic aesthetic while modern amenities provide the comfort of home. Minutes from famous naturalist attractions in all directions. Enjoy the entire peaceful cottage and surrounding yard with outdoor seating, fire pit, and hot tub to yourself. Three acres of adjoining trails and creek shared with neighboring host family, who are fun-loving and approachable but respect your privacy.
$252 per night
Cottage in Aurora
Heron Cottage on Cayuga Lake
Heron Cottage is a newly renovated, year-round lakeside getaway on Cayuga Lake! Just 2 miles south of Aurora, and a 5 minute walk to Long Point State Park with access to a public boat launch, swimming/playground/picnic area and stunning lake views. This cozy cottage offers a truly unique experience with beautiful lakeviews and 22 acres of private wooded trails behind it. Heron Cottage is the perfect spot to enjoy Fingerlakes wineries & breweries and is minutes from The Inns of Aurora.
$235 per night
Cabin in Seneca Falls
Finger Lakes: Private Cottage on Lake
Full house on Lake; 3 min from the New York Chiropractic College; 10 min from the historical town of Seneca Falls, Montezuma National Wildlife Refuge, and nearby Finger Lakes wineries. You can swim right off the deck using the ladder (summer), fish, Kayak (2 available + life jackets). Beach and a boat ramp in Cayuga Lake State Park (2 min up the road). In the winter, cross-country ski and ice skating rings nearby (Geneva; Watkins Glen). New lock for easy check-in.
$189 per night

Other great vacation rentals in Cayuga Lake

Cottage in King Ferry
Experience Minka Life: Simple is good.
$143 per night
Tiny home in Seneca Falls
Luxury *Lakefront* Cayuga Cottage
$279 per night
Rental unit in Hector
Private Lakefront on Seneca Wine Trail
$160 per night
Cottage in Interlaken
$232 per night
Cottage in Branchport
Comfort and Luxury- Keuka Lake Dream Property
$300 per night
Cottage in Seneca Falls
Cayuga House - A Private Cottage on Cayuga Lake
$266 per night
Chalet in Canandaigua
The Johnson Chalet in Bristol/Canandaigua*HOT TUB*
$230 per night
Home in Geneva
Sunsets on Seneca Lake
$240 per night
Cabin in Hector
Wine Trail Cabin with a view -cabin 2
$177 per night
Cabin in Freeville
Charming Cabin in Spruce Forest
$209 per night
Cottage in Seneca Falls
Cozy 2 Bedroom Cayuga Waterfront Cottage
$352 per night
Home in Union Springs
Lake Home on Cayuga- Kayaks provided!
$269 per night
  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Cayuga Lake