Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Castle Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Castle Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Buckeye Lake Lakeview Cottage by Epic Suites
Entire cottage · 6 guests · 3 beds · 1 bath
Buckeye Lake Lakeview Cottage by Epic SuitesEnjoy the relaxed side of Buckeye Lake! Updated cottage with a gorgeous water view of Buckeye Lake from the front deck! Brand new furnishings, comfortable beds and updates throughout. This cottage is on the quieter side of Buckeye Lake but right by the marina, restaurants and all the entertainment the lake has to offer. Wake up to a warm cup of coffee and enjoy the view.
Terrace Retreat on the Canal with Boat Dock
Entire cottage · 6 guests · 6 beds · 2 baths
Terrace Retreat on the Canal with Boat DockKick back & relax. Have a boat? We have a dock! Cozy, bright, clean, very chic and perfect for guests who likes a little luxury. Love to cook or bake? No problem! The kitchen is fully equipped! Want to eat out? There are plenty of restaurants around the lake. There's also a gas grill and party barn, complete with fire pit. Whether you want to chill with friends and family, fish from the canal or use your boat, this upscale cottage is ideal for pleasure seekers.
New Home - "See More" at the lake
SUPERHOST
Entire residential home · 6 guests · 3 beds · 1.5 baths
New Home - "See More" at the lakeBrand new home just blocks from the North Shore State Park and boat launch. A short walk to some of the best restaurants, bars and views on the lake. Modern design, comfortable 3 bedroom home with ample dining space and fully stocked kitchen. Offering a nice backyard for a game of cornhole or outdoor dining. Ranch style home makes this property easily accessible for unpacking and relaxing. Enjoy time around the lake on the water or biking the 4 mile path along the north shore.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

  • Homes
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Other great vacation rentals in Castle Island

  1. Entire cottage
  2. Buckeye
The Paddle Inn-Buckeye Lake cottage on the Water
$207 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire cottage
  2. Thornville
Little House on Buckeye Lake
$185 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Thornville
Lakefront Buckeye Lake Family Retreat
$155 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Buckeye Lake
Beautiful Lake House in Buckeye Lake, Ohio.
$429 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire cottage
  2. Buckeye Lake
Cozy Rose Cottage @ Buckeye Lake
$127 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire cottage
  2. Buckeye Lake
Grammy’sCottage by the Lake 3BR1.5BA Sleeps 5 WiFi
$89 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire loft
  2. Thornville
Large studio near Buckeye Lake: no smoking
$87 per night
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Hebron
Home away from home - fenced yard a block to lake
$165 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Thornville
Stunning 3BR Waterfront home on Buckeye Lake
$385 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Camper/RV
  2. Thornville
Lakefront Airstream Retreat at Buckeye Lake
$140 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire rental unit
  2. Thornville
Narcissus Place: non smoking
$73 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Buckeye Lake
Adorable Buckeye Lake Cottage
$251 per night