Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Butternuts

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Butternuts

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Cottage in Oxford
✨Lakeside Reflections
Lakeside Reflections is a year-round lakeside cottage in the quiet upstate NY countryside with pristine views of Lake Gerry. Come enjoy our peaceful nook of historic Oxford complete with gardens, decks, docks, boats, and modern amenities. Grill out on the lakefront deck, or fish directly off the deck! Jump in the lake, or take a kayak, paddle boat, or walk around the lake. Enjoy one of the many local attractions such as the famous Northeast Classic Car Museum (see our Airbnb guidebook for ideas)
$144 per night
Cabin in South New Berlin
Corner's Cabin - A-Frame Cabin - Catskills NY
Get a true cabin experience! This A-Frame cabin is tucked away by green landscapes. Near the catskill region of Upstate NY, 40 minutes from The Baseball Hall Of Frame, and Field of Dreams Sport Complex in Cooperstown. The outside area has a deck with furniture, a fire pit area with chairs, a hammock, pond views, and more The inside is a wooden hand built cabin, containing a spiral staircase leading to the loft area, a full kitchen, a propane fire place, and office spaces with high speed wifi
$117 per night
Cabin in Unadilla
Hilltop Camp with a View
Located on a quiet, beautiful country road in Unadilla, NY sits our Hilltop Camp with an incredible view that lets you see for miles. We are a few short minutes from the Majors Inn, the Gilbertsville Farmhouse, and Far View Farms and also conveniently located to Oneonta and Cooperstown Dreams Park. Copes Corner Park is 3 miles away on the Butternut Creek where you can fish or launch a kayak or canoe. The Unadilla Drive-In, breweries, snowmobile trails, and places to hike are also nearby.
$152 per night

Stay near Butternuts's top sights

Photo of Gilbertsville Farmhouse & NY Goat Yoga
Gilbertsville Farmhouse & NY Goat Yoga8 locals recommend
Photo of Weaver's Farm Market
Weaver's Farm Market8 locals recommend
Photo of The Empire House Hotel
The Empire House Hotel6 locals recommend

Other great vacation rentals in Butternuts

Rental unit in Gilbertsville
Signature Quilt Bed and Breakfast
$120 per night
Rental unit in Norwich
Fun Bohemian Retro Apartment
$105 per night
Loft in Otego
Cozy Otego Apartment
$132 per night
Cabin in Otego
Catskills Over Water Bungalow on Lake Albanese!
$265 per night
Home in Laurens
Log home, minutes to all star village in Oneonta
$275 per night
Home in Morris
Miller Farmhouse in Butternuts NY
$250 per night
Cabin in Laurens
Luxury Catskills Log Cabin Lakeside Hot Tub, Boats
$228 per night
Rental unit in Sidney
Executive Suite Newly renovated.
$85 per night
Cottage in Oxford
Beaver Palace Studios and Estates relaxing getaway
$91 per night
Rental unit in Oxford
Breezy Meadow
$100 per night
Guesthouse in Norwich
Fully furnished apartment
$49 per night
Guest suite in Oneonta
Sunrise Suite
$136 per night
  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Otsego County
  5. Butternuts