Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Butterfield Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Butterfield Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Rental unit in Redwood
A Simple Roof
THIS IS NOT A VACATION HOME. Self-check-in/check-out. Old-fashioned, rustic apartment, painted wood floors, full kitchen, mud room, screened porch; boat/ATV parking; tent space. Ready for year-round outdoor sports, fishing, boating, biking, family camping trips. Near 1000 Islands, several lakes/waterways, 5 room apartment is one side of host duplex, 3 private entrances. King bed, 1 twin, 2 folding cots. WIFI; NO cable/dish service/HDMI cord provided; TVs w/DVD; bring firestick. RED box nearby.
$49 per night
Cottage in Theresa
Moon Lake Cottage
Relax with the family at this peaceful place to stay. This is a 3 bedroom home located at the end of a private road, there is lake access, the lake is quaint best for bass in the summer & ice fishing in the winter. The lake itself is shallow so it ices over thick in the winter and the water is warm in the summer. Closest to Theresa where there is small shops,coffee,gas and convenience. Within 30 miles of Alexandria Bay & the thousand islands(Boldt Castle) and shopping centers in Watertown.
$105 per night
Cottage in Redwood
Camp Loon near Butterfield Lake/ Alexandria Bay
Recently renovated, very clean Non- Smoking cottage adjacent to Butterfield Lake in Redwood, NY. This cozy 1 bedroom cottage is perfect for 4 who would enjoy fishing and relaxing by the water. . The double bed sofa folds flat for 2 children or 2 smaller adults. (No more than 4 guests per night at this listing.) Prior to booking get approval for pet. ($30 charge per each pet). There is wifi, TV and DVR. Guests may bring their Firestick or Roku for watching TV as there is no cable.
$121 per night

Other great vacation rentals in Butterfield Lake

Serviced apartment in Gouverneur
$91 per night
Serviced apartment in Gouverneur
Captain’s Quarters at Water’s Edge
$69 per night
Cottage in Alexandria Bay
Island Cottage @ The Ledges Resort & Marina
$159 per night
Cabin in Redwood
Rustic Lakefront Cabin on Beautiful Millsite Lake
$150 per night
Home in Theresa
Moon Lake Retreat🌙Bright, clean, steps from water
$199 per night
Rental unit in Wellesley Island
Waterfront Wellesley Island Apt w/ Private Dock!
$125 per night
Cottage in Leeds and the Thousand Islands
Smugglers Getaway Riverfront B&B
$169 per night
Home in Philadelphia
Peaceful Countryside Retreat
$202 per night
Guesthouse in Rockport
Adorable two bedroom guesthouse on the River
$92 per night
Cottage in Alexandria Bay
Super Clean, Pet Friendly Cottage! NO EXTRA FEES!!
$135 per night
Rental unit in Evans Mills
Cozy two-bedroom apartment, in Evans Mills.
$99 per night
Private room in Redwood
The Guest House. Private BR, Bath & Family Room
$75 per night